Afternoon, toastmasters and guests.
How to not win when one is clearly the best? When rule’s been breached, yet one proceeds to take part in the contest.
We had the humorous and evaluation contests last Saturday for the area level. It’s not only managing one’s nerves and scripting a winning speech that I learned, but also other lessons.
When I saw the position of the timing device, I told the division director it’s hard for contestants to take note of the timing device located at the extreme end of the speaking space.
He said that judges were not supposed to take into account the timing in their evaluation so the timing device had to be out of sight of the judges.
Jun aired his concern when contest chair mentioned at the beginning of the contest position of the timing device.
Pradeep had an issue with the position of the timing device as well.
Despite these, the contest carried on without the timing device repositioned.
Pradeep clearly was the best contestant in speech evaluation but he was disqualified as a result of busting the time limit.
I read the rulebook after that and it is stated “The signalling device must be in full view of each contestant” and timing signals shall be clearly visible to the speakers but not obvious to the audience.
Apparently, the organising committee breached this rule. But because we did not take further action despite taking issue with the position of the timing device and Pradeep went on to take part, we were at fault as well.
What are the lessons learned here?
1. Don’t compromise if you have a legitimate issue, even if it means you give up the opportunity. As president of this club, I would support and respect your decision.
2. Familiarise yourself with the rules and refer to the rulebook when in doubt. I should have done this when I brought up the issue before the contest started but I trusted others instead.
Michael Phelps said nobody is happy to lose but he was very gracious when he lost to Joseph Schooling.
To me, taking part in contests, the means to the end is that matters.
It might be easy for me to say this because I wasn’t a contestant. But i think the ultimate question is, have you done your best. If the answer is “yes”, you are a winner no matter what.